1946 Evelyn Kiester
1947 Ruth Foreman
1948 Louise Mears
1949 Mary Jesenko
1950 Luetta Edick
1951 Aileen Lane
1952 Elaine VanDerhoff
1953 Elsie Jesenko
1954 Elaine Blackstock
1955 Judy Dobbin
1956 Donna Dines
1957 Shirley Titmus
1958 Mary Jesenko
1959 Anita Maher
1960 Sandra Cook
1961 Mary Levanger
1962 Rayola Black
1963 Margene Gabica
1964 Dani Lee Downing
1965 Marie Jerebx

1966 Elaine Vail
1967 Cathy Cook
1968 Nancy Ellis
1969 Mary Ann Black
1970 Linda Tyson
1971 Jane Maggard
1972 Donna Basey
1973 Sheree Johnston
1974 Janie Stillwell
1975 Gina Pickett
1976 Debbie Basey
1977 Merilee Eason
1978 Earlyn Chase
1979 Carla King
1980 Heather Keith
1981 Valerie Eason
1982 Jenine Youcker
1983 Kelly Cossell
1984 Linda Nix
1985 Brenda Ball

1986 Michelle Lane
1987 Andrea Schlapia
1988 Debbie McKee
1989 Stacey Eckhout
1990 Tina Fuller
1991 Shawna Roberts
1992 Kristi Becken
1993 Christy Hall
1994 Lisa Clark
1995 Jonni Lynch
1996 Megan Tanner
1997 Jennifer Kolar
1998 Jessica Beutler
1999 Shanna Painter
2000 Ginger King
2001 Janelle Sloyer
2002 Miranda Volk
2003 Claire Gaudry
2004 Sarah M. Boyer
2005 Hailey Rose Hall

2006 Sarah Louise Bass
2007 Dannielle Kidder
2008 Randi Turner
2009 Leslie Winkelman
2010 Jessica Will
2011 Cassie Nielsen
2012 Annie Kunerth
2013 Bonnie Crisci
2014 Miranda Wilkins
2015 Jaycee Engle
2016 Mandy Allison
2017 Bo Bourasa
2018 Tevis Mashore
2019 Emma Carley
2020 Annie Miller
2021 Hannah White
2022 Ella Boren
2023 Becky Green

2024 Allison Hubler